Propane vs Butane BBQ Gas: Which Should You Use in the UK?

Propane vs Butane BBQ Gas: Which Should You Use in the UK?

Posted by Amy Hall on 20th Nov 2026

Propane vs Butane BBQ Gas: Which Should You Use in the UK?

Hand-drawn barbecue gas and cylinder title card

For most UK gas barbecues, propane is the right choice. It still turns to gas in freezing weather, it can live outside all year, and it is the fuel sold as green “patio gas”, which is what most barbecues are built to take. Butane is a fuel for mild weather and small portable grills. Whichever you buy, the real test is simple: use the gas, bottle and regulator your barbecue’s manufacturer specifies.

Great Gardens Online
Set Up Your Outdoor Cooking Space
Explore garden furniture and outdoor living products from Great Gardens Online to help make your space more enjoyable.

TL;DR

  • Propane works in the cold and is the standard outdoor barbecue fuel. Calor says it turns to gas at -42°C, while butane boils at -2°C.
  • Butane suits warm evenings and small portable grills, but it can stall once temperatures fall towards 5°C.
  • Patio gas is propane in a green bottle with a clip-on connection. It is not a third fuel.
  • Match the regulator to your barbecue’s data plate, not just to the gas.
  • Keep bottles outside, and never bring a propane bottle or a barbecue indoors.

Table of Contents

Propane vs butane: the difference that matters

Propane and butane are both LPG (liquefied petroleum gas), stored as a liquid under pressure in a bottle and released as a gas when you open the valve. They burn in a very similar way. The difference is the temperature at which each one turns from liquid into gas.

Calor, the UK bottled gas supplier, gives the figures: propane vaporises at -42°C and butane at -2°C. In practice, butane loses pressure well before it reaches that point. Yorkshire Gas Supplies reports that butane performs well above 5°C but deteriorates significantly below it. On a cool British June evening, a butane bottle can leave you with a weak flame and half-cooked sausages.

Propane Butane
Turns to gas at -42°C -2°C
Reliable in cold weather Yes Becomes unreliable below about 5°C
Where to store the bottle Outdoors, all year Outdoors in summer; ideally a shed or garage in winter
Typical use Outdoor BBQs, patio heaters Small portable grills, indoor flueless heaters, leisure appliances
Typical bottle colour Red (screw-in) or green (patio gas, clip-on) Blue

The heat output also differs a little. Energas says propane’s higher calorific value gives a hotter grill and faster preheating, which suits larger multi-burner barbecues. It also says butane can be more economical for smaller portable grills used in warmer months, and always advises checking the barbecue maker’s instructions for the recommended gas.

What about “propane or butane for a BBQ” if you only cook in summer?

If you cook only on warm days, butane can work, but it leaves you with no margin. A spring lunch, an autumn bonfire-night cook-up or a Boxing Day grill all fall in butane’s weak zone. Propane lets you decide when to cook by appetite rather than by thermometer. For a family barbecue that sits on the patio, that flexibility is worth more than anything else on the comparison table.

What is patio gas?

Patio gas is the name you will see on green bottles, and it causes more confusion than any other label. Adams Gas explains that patio gas is propane. The “patio” name is a marketing label for a propane bottle with a clip-on regulator connection, made for outdoor equipment such as gas barbecues and patio heaters.

Calor’s gas bottle guide adds that patio gas suits a 27mm clip-on regulator, and that whether you need a screw-in or clip-on bottle depends on your barbecue’s regulator. So “propane or butane” is often really a choice between three bottle types:

  1. Green patio gas: propane, clip-on connection. This is the usual match for a standard retail barbecue.
  2. Red propane: the same fuel, but with a screw-in connection and a higher-pressure regulator.
  3. Blue butane: a different fuel, a different regulator and lower operating pressure.

Foyle Gas notes that a patio bottle will not connect to a screw-fit propane regulator. The simplest rule when you replace a bottle is to match the old one: same gas, same size, same valve.

How to check which gas and regulator your barbecue needs

This is the step where most mistakes happen, because the regulator, the small valve that steps bottle pressure down to what your burners can handle, must fit both the bottle and the appliance.

Step 1: read the data plate and manual

Every gas barbecue has a data plate or a section in the manual stating the gas type and operating pressure. Four Seasons Fuel says to look for this figure: typically 28 mbar for butane and 37 mbar for propane. If the manual says propane at 37 mbar, you need a propane bottle and a regulator rated for it.

Step 2: match the connection

Most barbecues come with a standard 27mm clip-on regulator for green patio bottles. According to Calor, red propane cylinders are incompatible with most standard barbecues unless the barbecue is fitted with a screw-in, high-pressure, adjustable propane regulator. Do not force or adapt a connection that does not fit.

Step 3: pick a bottle size you can lift

Size is a practical decision as much as a technical one. Energas lists red propane cylinders in 3.9kg, 6kg, 11kg, 12.7kg, 19kg and 47.2kg sizes, and blue butane in 4.5kg, 7kg and 13kg. For a three- or four-burner barbecue on a patio, a larger bottle means fewer changeovers, but a full 13kg bottle is heavy to carry, so think about where it will live and how far you must move it.

Step 4: check the bottle and the fittings

Calor tests its cylinders every five years, and the test date is stamped on the collar. A code such as D26 means due October to December 2026. Calor’s patio gas safety leaflet recommends replacing rubber hoses after five years’ service and replacing older BS:3016 regulators, which are over ten years old. Four Seasons Fuel gives the same ten-year and five-year guideline for regulators and hoses.

Step 4: check the bottle and the fittings

Step 5: test for leaks

After connecting a new bottle, Liquid Gas UK, the UK LPG trade association, advises checking for leaks with soapy water. Brush it on the joints and watch for bubbles. If you see any, turn the gas off at the bottle and do not use the barbecue until the fault is fixed. Our guide to gas BBQ setup for UK beginners covers the leak check and the clearance you need around the barbecue in more detail.

Is propane cheaper than butane?

There is no clean answer, because you pay for the bottle (a deposit-style “new” price) once and then for each refill, and bottle sizes differ. Calor’s published LPG price list is a useful snapshot of how the two compare. At the time it was read in 2026, with a temporary volatility surcharge on top, it showed:

Bottle New Refill
5kg propane patio gas £73.24 £23.25
13kg propane patio gas £107.49 £52.50
4.5kg butane £82.99 £33.00
7kg butane £85.99 £36.00
15kg butane £106.49 £56.50

These are suggested prices that vary between stockists and move with the wholesale gas market, so treat them as a guide to the pattern and check the live list before you buy. The pattern is clear: a first bottle costs a good deal more than a refill, and propane refills are not dearer than butane ones of similar size. Judged per cook rather than per kilogram, propane’s hotter flame and year-round reliability make it the better value for a barbecue you use regularly.

Safety: where the gas goes and where it never goes

This part is not a matter of preference.

  • Outdoors only for propane. Calor’s help page says patio gas cylinders are for outdoor use only, and that red propane bottles must always be used and stored outside. Liquid Gas UK warns that bringing propane indoors creates a risk of carbon monoxide build-up and fire.
  • Butane indoors is for specific appliances. Butane can be used indoors only with specially designed flueless appliances, such as mobile heaters. It is not a licence to cook on a barbecue in the kitchen or garage.
  • Never in a tent, marquee or enclosed space. Calor’s leaflet is explicit that patio gas appliances must never be used in an enclosed space, tent or marquee because of fire risk and carbon monoxide, which is colourless, odourless and tasteless. Its symptoms can resemble a viral infection.
  • Fit a carbon monoxide alarm. The same leaflet recommends a detector marked BS:EN:50291 in every property.
  • Store away from heat and sun. Calor says bottles belong outdoors, away from heat sources and direct sunlight, because a leak or a valve not fully closed can let gas build up.
  • Cold-weather butane. Liquid Gas UK advises against using butane in very cold weather, as it may not work properly. In winter, Yorkshire Gas Supplies suggests keeping butane bottles in a shed or garage.

If you have children in the garden, keep the barbecue and bottle in a fixed spot away from play areas, and read our BBQ safety guide for parents. If you ever smell gas, turn the valve off, move away and follow the emergency advice printed on your supplier’s literature.

Choosing by the kind of barbecue you own

A freestanding 3 to 4 burner barbecue. Propane in a green patio bottle, with the clip-on regulator it came with, unless the manual says otherwise. This is the standard setup for a family patio.

A small portable or tabletop grill. Check the manual first. Some are designed for butane or small disposable-style cartridges, and some for propane. Butane is workable in summer, but a propane-rated model gives you more months of use.

A barbecue in a rental property. Landlords should supply the barbecue only with clear instructions on the gas type and bottle, and a reminder that bottles are stored outside. Fewer variables mean fewer problems for tenants.

A barbecue built into an outdoor kitchen. Fixed installations need more planning for where the bottle sits and how it is ventilated. If you are designing a whole space, outdoor kitchen design ideas can help you picture the layout before you decide where the gas supply goes.

Choosing by the kind of barbecue you own

Not sure gas is the right fuel at all? Our comparisons of charcoal vs gas BBQs and electric BBQ vs gas set out the trade-offs, including speed, flavour and set-up.

Our view on propane and butane

We would rather you enjoy a barbecue in March than wonder why the flame has died in June. That is why our advice is plain: if you are buying a gas barbecue for a family garden, plan around propane.

The mistakes we hear described most often are small ones. A bottle that does not fit, a regulator for the wrong gas, a hose that has aged. Each is avoided by reading the data plate, matching the old bottle like for like, and treating the garden as the only place gas ever goes.

A barbecue is part of how you use the whole space. A good table and chairs, shelter and somewhere sensible to put the bottle make the difference between a barbecue you use twice a year and one you use every week. That is how we choose and describe the garden and outdoor living products we sell.

Peter

Make the space around your barbecue work

Once the gas is sorted, the rest of the setup is about comfort. We stock outdoor dining sets for eating beside the grill, chimeneas and outdoor heating for cooler evenings, and garden furniture to complete a patio. Orders over £70 qualify for free delivery, and you can return items within 14 days.

Great Gardens Online

If you also plan a fire pit or chiminea beside the barbecue, our guides to fire pit fuel in the UK and chiminea vs fire pit explain what each burns and what that means for safety.

FAQ

Can I use propane in a barbecue designed for butane?

Only if the manufacturer’s instructions allow it. Propane and butane run at different operating pressures, typically 37 mbar and 28 mbar respectively, so the regulator must match the gas. Do not swap the gas without checking the data plate and fitting the correct regulator.

Is patio gas the same as propane?

Yes. Patio gas is propane sold in green bottles with a clip-on regulator connection, made for barbecues and patio heaters. The name is a marketing label rather than a different fuel. Red propane bottles contain the same gas but use a screw-in connection.

Which is safer indoors, butane or propane?

Neither is for use with a barbecue indoors. Liquid Gas UK says only butane cylinders should be used indoors, and only with appliances designed for it, such as flueless heaters. Propane bottles must always be stored and used outside, and barbecues are for outdoor use only.

What size gas bottle do I need for a BBQ?

The size depends on how often you cook and how far you can move the bottle. Propane comes in sizes from 3.9kg to 47.2kg, and patio gas commonly in 5kg and 13kg sizes. Choose a size that fits your regulator and that you can lift safely.

Should I keep the bottle outside in winter?

Propane bottles can stay outdoors all year, according to Yorkshire Gas Supplies, away from heat sources and direct sunlight. Butane is best kept in a shed or garage in winter. Neither should be stored inside the house.

Sources