Electric BBQ vs Gas: Which Is Right for Your Garden?
Posted by Amy Hall on 17th Nov 2026
Electric BBQ vs Gas: Which Is Right for Your Garden?

Choose an electric barbecue if you have a small garden, patio or balcony, want to cook within minutes and don’t need to feed a crowd. Choose gas if you cook for larger groups, want proper searing heat and have somewhere safe outdoors to keep a cylinder. Neither is the “better” barbecue in general. The right one depends on your space, your guest list and how much weather you cook in, and this guide takes you through each of those so you can decide with confidence.
TL;DR
- Electric suits small spaces, quick weeknight cooking and beginners. It needs a mains socket, stays compact and is the cheapest to run.
- Gas suits bigger gardens and bigger groups. It gives steady, adjustable heat, several burners for different zones and a choice of sizes, but you need to store and swap a gas cylinder.
- Flavour: charcoal still leads on smoke. Electric and gas sit closer together, and some electric models now add a wood-chip smoker box.
- Safety: never use any barbecue indoors, under an awning or in a tent. Check your lease before putting any barbecue on a balcony.
- Pellet grills are the set-and-forget smokers: large and flavourful, but slower to heat and costlier to feed.
Table of Contents
- Electric or gas: the quick comparison
- How they cook: heat, control and flavour
- What each costs to buy and to run
- Size, weather and where you live
- Safety: what to know before you light up
- Where pellet grills fit in
- Which should you choose?
- Keeping it clean
- Build the whole outdoor space
- Our view on choosing a barbecue
- FAQ
- Sources
Electric or gas: the quick comparison
| Electric | Gas | |
|---|---|---|
| Heat-up | Quick | About 10 minutes |
| Temperature control | Precise, dial-based | Adjustable knobs, several burners |
| Size range | Mostly compact | Compact to large family models |
| Fuel | Mains socket | Propane or butane cylinder |
| Cleaning | No ash, simple | No ash, but drip trays and burners need attention |
| Weather | Not suited to wet weather | Copes better outdoors |
| Best for | Balconies, small patios, beginners | Gardens, family cooking, regular entertaining |
The heat-up and size points come from Which?'s comparison of electric, gas and charcoal and T3’s fuel guide, which puts gas at around 10 minutes to reach cooking temperature.
How they cook: heat, control and flavour
Electric: easy and even
An electric barbecue works by heating elements, a bit like an oven with a grill plate on top. Which? lists quick heat-up, easy setup and straightforward cleaning among the strengths, and says electric models keep a good cooking temperature without constant food-shifting, unlike gas barbecues that can suffer flare-ups and hot and cold spots. A flare-up is when dripping fat catches fire and flames leap up around the food.
Good Housekeeping adds that electric models give more precise temperatures and are easy to store. That makes them a gentle place to start if you have never cooked outdoors before.
Some models go further. The same Which? article says its testing found the complaint about missing smoky flavour isn’t necessarily true, pointing to one model with a pellet smoker box and another with well-charred results. The Telegraph’s review describes a compact model with top and bottom heating elements that can grill and air fry, with a smoker box for wood chips.
Gas: steady flame, more zones
Gas gives you a constant flame with less risk of the temperature dropping. Many models have several burners, and some have side burners, so you can run one area hot for searing and another cooler for chicken or vegetables. That is hard to match on a small electric unit.
Gas is also easy to light, has no ash to clean and, according to Which?'s 2026 gas and electric review guide, often comes with features such as fat drip trays and vapourisers that create smoke from the drips. Good Housekeeping notes that a gas flame is cooler than charcoal, so you will get less of that fierce, restaurant-style sear unless the model is built for it.
What about flavour?
Be realistic about the smoke. The Guardian’s June 2026 tested-barbecue guide says charcoal gives the best flavour, because juices drip onto hot coals and burn into smoke. It places gas in the middle and describes basic electric grills as little more than hot plates.
If smoky taste matters most, look at gas models with a lid and flavouriser bars, or at electric models with a wood-chip smoker box. If you are weighing charcoal as well, our guide to charcoal against gas barbecues covers speed against smoke in more detail.
Whichever you pick, a lid helps. The Guardian’s guide says a lid makes lighting easier and locks in moisture, and that a hinged lid is handier than a removable one.
What each costs to buy and to run
Buying
Electric barbecues cover a wide range. In April 2026, The Telegraph’s test of six electric models found prices running from about £80 for a basic model without a lid to about £900 for sophisticated ones. Gas barbecues are generally pricier than charcoal, as Which? notes, and prices rise with the number of burners and the build quality.
Prices move with sales and seasons, so treat any figure as a snapshot and check the product page when you buy.
Running
T3’s fuel comparison, updated in May 2024, put an electric grill at about 60p an hour for an average 2.4kW model, against around £35 for a 5kg gas cylinder. It concluded that electricity is generally the cheapest fuel per session. Electricity prices change with your tariff and the regulator’s price cap, so work out your own figure: multiply the barbecue’s wattage in kilowatts by the hours of cooking and by your unit rate per kWh on your bill.
A worked example: a 2kW barbecue running for 1.5 hours uses 3kWh. At a unit rate of 30p per kWh, that is 90p for the session. The same session on gas depends on the cylinder size and how many burners you run, so gas costs vary more from one cook to the next.
Which? also points out that running an electric model regularly can raise the electricity bill. If you barbecue most evenings in summer, it is worth including that in your sums.
Size, weather and where you live
Small spaces
Electric models are the natural choice for a patio or a small garden. Which? chef James Adams calls them excellent for beginners and smaller spaces such as balconies, patios or smaller gardens. If you are planning a compact cooking corner, our small garden BBQ ideas include layouts and safety checks for UK patios.

When shopping, the John Lewis outdoor barbecue buyer quoted by The Telegraph advises looking for at least 1,500 to 2,000 watts for efficient heating, with temperature control essential.
Feeding a crowd
Electric barbecues are typically smaller and less suited to large gatherings. A family of four is fine. Twelve people at a birthday means cooking in batches, and a larger gas barbecue with multiple burners makes that far easier.
Weather and the mains
Electric barbecues need a mains plug at all times and aren’t suitable for wet weather. That means an outdoor-rated socket within reach, a cable that doesn’t trail across a path, and a plan for rainy days. Some manufacturers fit rechargeable batteries, so a few models don’t always need the mains.
Gas needs no socket, so you can place it anywhere in the garden. In exchange you need somewhere to keep the cylinder, and a little care when you connect it. Our gas BBQ setup guide for UK beginners walks through connecting safely and keeping clear space around the unit.

Safety: what to know before you light up
Some points apply to every barbecue. GOV.UK’s fire safety outdoors guidance says to keep a bucket of water, sand or a hose nearby, never use a barbecue indoors, in a tent, under an awning or in a caravan, and keep children and pets away. Let the barbecue cool before you move it.
For gas, the same guidance says:
- Store cylinders outside, away from direct sunlight and frost, and never under the stairs.
- Turn the cylinder tap off before changing the cylinder, and change it outdoors or in a well-ventilated area.
- After cooking, turn the gas supply off first, then the barbecue control.
- If you suspect a leak, brush soapy water around the joints and watch for bubbles.
For balconies, London Fire Brigade advises against using a barbecue on a balcony because flames, sparks and hot embers can spread fire through the building. It also advises placing a barbecue on level ground, not decking, well away from sheds, fences and trees, and never leaving it unattended. If you rent or live in a flat, read your lease or tenancy agreement and ask the landlord or managing agent in writing before you buy.
Charcoal and gas barbecues can also give off carbon monoxide. London Fire Brigade’s booklet warns that a smouldering barbecue can keep producing it for many hours, so never take one into a home, tent or caravan. If you suspect carbon monoxide poisoning, leave immediately, seek medical attention and call the Gas Emergency Number, 0800 111 999.
Electric models avoid combustion, but the usual electrical care applies: keep the flex clear of walkways, keep the unit on a stable surface and keep it dry.
Where pellet grills fit in
Pellet grills burn compressed wood pellets fed automatically from a hopper, so they act as a smoker and grill in one. Many people searching for electric or gas barbecues also ask about them, so here is the short version.
The good: Trusted Reviews’ 2026 review of a Traeger pellet grill lists effortless set-and-forget cooking, large capacity, tender smoky results and precise digital temperature control.
The trade-offs to plan for: the same review found 20 minutes to reach 400°F, a temperature drop of up to 100°F when the lid stays open a while, and about 13.5kg of pellets used on a long low-and-slow cook, with a 9kg bag costing £25 to £35. Pellet grills also run on electricity to power the feed and controls. They suit people who love slow-cooked brisket or ribs and cook that way regularly. For quick weeknight sausages and burgers, an electric or gas model is quicker and cheaper to fuel.
Against charcoal, pellets give you more control and less tending. Charcoal still wins for classic smoky flavour and high heat, but it is slower to heat and harder to clean.
Which should you choose?
Choose electric if:
- you have a balcony (with permission), small patio or compact garden
- you cook for two to four people
- you want fast, predictable results with no fuel to buy
- you are new to barbecuing
Choose gas if:
- you entertain larger groups regularly
- you want multiple heat zones for steaks, chicken and vegetables at once
- you have a safe outdoor spot to store a cylinder
- you want to cook anywhere in the garden without a socket
Think about a pellet grill if:
- you want to smoke food low and slow and don’t mind the pellet cost
Renting out a property or setting up a family garden
Landlords should check tenancy clauses before supplying any barbecue. Rules differ between leases, and some ban open flame only while others ban any cooking apparatus on a balcony. For a private garden attached to a let, a sturdy gas or electric model gives tenants a reason to use the space, and a simple instruction note on cylinder storage helps.
If you have young children, position the barbecue well away from play areas, keep a clear zone round it while it is hot and let it cool fully before anyone gets close, as the GOV.UK guidance advises.
Keeping it clean
A clean barbecue cooks better and lasts longer. Electric models are the simplest: let the plate cool, wipe it down and empty the drip tray. Gas barbecues need hot grates scraped, drip trays emptied and burners checked. Our guides to cleaning a gas BBQ in six steps and UK barbecue cleaning cover both. Good Housekeeping also advises preheating the grill every time, which helps cut cooking time and kill residual bacteria.
Build the whole outdoor space
Once you have picked your barbecue, the rest of the garden is where the summer is won. A dining set, a shaded spot and somewhere to sit and eat turn a quick cook-out into an evening outdoors. At Great Gardens Online you can browse outdoor dining and garden furniture, along with planters, chimeneas and decor to finish the space.
We offer free delivery on orders over £70, next-day delivery options and returns within 14 days, so you can plan furniture around your barbecue without a rush.

If you would like to see everything in one place, start on the Great Gardens Online home page.
Our view on choosing a barbecue
We think the best barbecue is the one you will use every week, not the one that looks most impressive in the shop. That usually comes down to space. A compact patio is a perfect fit for a plug-in electric model, while a family garden with regular get-togethers rewards a gas barbecue with room to cook for everyone.
Whichever you choose, think of the barbecue as part of an outdoor room. A table where everyone can sit, a bit of shelter and a tidy spot for pots and planters make cooking outside feel like an occasion. That is why we stock barbecues alongside garden furniture, outdoor dining, planters, chimeneas and decor, so you can plan the whole space together.
Our customers tell us on Trustpilot that they value easy ordering and quick delivery, and we keep returns simple, with 14 days to change your mind. Take your time, measure your patio and pick the barbecue that suits how you really cook.
Peter
FAQ
Are electric barbecues any good?
Yes, for the right job. Which? says they heat up quickly, hold a steady temperature and are easy to set up and clean. Their limits are size, the need for a mains socket and poor suitability for wet weather, so they work best on small patios and for smaller groups.
Do electric grills taste as good as gas grills?
They can come close for everyday grilling, but neither gives the deep smoke of charcoal. Basic electric grills are often compared to a hot plate. Models with a wood-chip smoker box add noticeably more smoky flavour, and gas models with a lid and drip trays create some smoke from the fat that falls.
What are the disadvantages of an electric barbecue?
Most are compact, so they struggle with big gatherings. They must be plugged in at all times, aren’t suited to wet weather and can lack a smoky taste. Running one often can also add to your electricity bill, so check your unit rate before you buy.
Do you leave the lid open on an electric barbecue?
It depends on the model and the food, so follow the maker’s instructions. A closed lid locks in moisture and heat for thicker cuts, while an open lid suits thin items you want to sear and turn quickly. Whichever you use, preheat the grill every time.
Is a gas or electric barbecue safer?
Both are safe when used properly. Gas needs correct cylinder storage and leak checks, while electric needs a dry, stable setup and a flex kept out of the way. Neither should be used indoors or in a tent, and balcony use needs your landlord’s or managing agent’s permission and fire brigade guidance in mind.
Sources
- Why your next barbecue should be electric, Which?
- Best gas and electric BBQs 2026, Which?
- The best UK BBQs for every budget, The Guardian
- Charcoal vs gas vs pellet vs electric, T3
- BBQ buying guide, Good Housekeeping UK
- Is the best electric BBQ better than charcoal and gas?, The Telegraph
- Traeger Woodridge review, Trusted Reviews
- Fire safety outdoors, GOV.UK
- BBQ safety, London Fire Brigade
- Carbon monoxide safety booklet, London Fire Brigade



